The 13 Eyeliner Pencils That Will not Smudge, Crack, Or Crease

Eyeliner may be arduous to good, and when you’ve discovered your look, it may be even more durable to interrupt out of your new norm. That stated, there are such a lot of formulation on the market which might be created with ease of use in thoughts and that assist you create a wide range of seems. When you’ve discovered the best way to use them, they might simply snag a everlasting spot in your routine.

Pat McGrath

Pat McGrath’s Labs Permagel Extremely Glide Eye Pencil is made utilizing silicone, so it strikes throughout the eyelid like a dream. It really works effectively if you’d like a crisp line, but when a smokey eye is extra your factor, you’ll be able to soften and smudge earlier than it units. It’s actually pigmented, too, so that you don’t should repeatedly hint over it.

Worth at time of publish: $29

Maybelline New York Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner

The 1.8-mm microtip on this pencil can be utilized to attract a cat eye and even means that you can get tremendous near the lash line—a troublesome feat—and it stays precisely the place you utilized it. The pencil mechanically twists up, so that you by no means have to fret about having a sharpener readily available, and it lasts for a whopping 24 hours of wear and tear. The gentle gel really feel makes it straightforward to make use of, as effectively.

Worth at time of publish: $9

If you’d like shade choices, the Marc Jacobs Magnificence Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner can ship. Starting from shimmer to matte to satin to sparkle finishes, there’s one thing for everybody. But it surely doesn’t finish there. The pencil itself is admittedly creamy and pigmented, so works effectively to create a powerful, dramatic line. And as soon as it units, it won’t transfer.

Worth at time of publish: $44

What Our Testers Say

“The liner didn’t smudge or run on me once I wore it on the highest lash line—I discovered that it actually held up by some lengthy days.” — Ashley Rebecca, Product Tester

Not solely are you able to select between 33 completely different colours, however you may as well select between matte, metallic, satin, shimmer, and glitter finishes. This eyeliner may be simply blended on the lid to create a smokey eye—and it provides a touch of moisture due to vitamin E and jojoba oil.

Worth at time of publish: $23

What We Like

InexpensiveWide shade vary
Creamy system

This liner is so good that it’s arduous to consider it’s solely $5. It’s actually creamy, so it glides on seamlessly, and the nice tip makes it straightforward to map out a refined line. It additionally is available in a variety of colours (assume gold, mint inexperienced, lavender, and bronze), so you’ll be able to match your make-up to your temper, and at that worth, who wouldn’t need to?

Worth at time of publish: $5 for Charcoal

Chantecaille

What We Like

Multidimensional shades
Pigmented
Lengthy-wearing

The identify says all of it, actually. This super-luxe French decide from Chantecaille is infused with silk powder, so it has an nearly liquid-like impact within the type of a pencil. It smudges barely however works greatest to ship a gentle, clear definition across the eye space. It’s tremendous wealthy in pigment, too.

Worth at time of publish: $33

SEPHORA COLLECTION 12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner

If you’d like a pencil that gained’t budge, you’ve obtained to do this spectacular choice from Sephora. It’s a waxy pencil, so will apply to the pores and skin easily however lock in place, leading to a line that lasts by sweat, humidity, oily lids, and tears. It’s tremendous opaque and is available in a variety of colours as effectively.

Worth at time of publish: $11

Kind: Pencil | Shades: 21 | Freed from: Parabens, talc, oil | Byrdie Clear: No | Cruelty-Free: No

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick

What We Like

Nice colour vary
Price range-friendly
Lengthy-lasting

The waterline is a tough spot to put on eyeliner as a result of the moisture from the attention may cause it to smudge and rub off, however this NYX choice defies the chances. It’s a very wealthy, creamy crayon that, as soon as set, gained’t budge. As soon as utilized, maintain your eyelid open for a second to provide it an opportunity to dry down.

Worth at time of publish: $8

Kind: Gel pencil | Shades: 34 | Freed from: | Byrdie Clear: | Cruelty-Free: Sure

What We Like

Clear system
Endurance
Nice applicator

That is a type of uncommon formulation that glides on extremely simply and truly stays put. That stated, it offers you ample time to mix or smudge after software. The gel system is in a roll-up tube that makes it straightforward to make use of and retains it sharp for precision. Lastly, the system is totally vegan, so that you don’t have to fret about any of the elements hurting delicate eyes.

Worth at time of publish: $26

Not solely can you employ this system to create wonderful precision seems, however it will also be simply blended and used for eyeshadow and even eyebrows. This makes it one of many simpler choices to make use of. Plus, it’s waterproof, so it can keep put that can assist you keep away from undesirable smudges.

Worth at time of publish: $25

Makeup by Mario Master Pigment Proâ¢ Eyeliner Pencil

What We Like

Precision brush included Wealthy pigment
Vegan and cruelty-free

This system encompasses a matte end and a significant pigment payoff. It’s gel-based and really delivers wealthy colour in just one swipe. Whereas one finish rolls up the liner, the opposite finish accommodates a precision brush that may make making a cat eye or detailed look a lot simpler. The comb is also used for mixing or spreading the liner as a shadow for a smokey look.

Worth at time of publish: $22

Charlotte Tilbury Matte & Metallic Double Ended Eyeliner - Eye Color Magic Collection

It is a nice choice for making a smokey eye as a result of it presents two completely different colours all inside one pencil. One half of the pencil is a matte black colour that may be nice for creating the preliminary define, and the opposite half is a champagne colour that can be utilized alongside the water line or inside nook of the attention. Each colours comprise emollient oils and pure waxes that make them glide on and mix with ease.

Worth at time of publish: $32

Danessa Myricks Beauty Infinite Chrome Waterproof Micropencil Eyeliner

What We Like

Distinctive colours
Metallic finishes
Waterproof

Not solely is that this colour distinctive, however it additionally seems darker in low-light areas and lighter in sunny areas. It has a metallic end and bronze undertones that may flatter any eye colour. The roll-up pencil means that you can create detailed seems, and the system is totally waterproof to get rid of smudging.

Worth at time of publish: $22

Last Verdict

Our high decide is Pat McGrath’s PermaGel Extremely Glide Eye Pencil due to its ultra-pigmented system and stand-out hues. In case you’re on the hunt for a finances choice, Maybelline New York’s Grasp Exact Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil is your greatest guess. Each are nice choices that can be utilized to create a wide range of seems that vary from ultra-pigmented to lighter daytime seems.

Meet the Skilled

Sam Michalska is a make-up artist & the Government Director of International Training at ILIA.

What To Look For When Shopping for An Eyeliner Pencil

Texture

Totally different eyeliner textures embrace gel, cream, kohl, liquid, and pencil. Most of those textures can be utilized to create comparable seems, so it’s extra about choice. With gel, cream, kohl, and pencil choices, whereas you will get closely pigmented formulation, these are usually higher fitted to those who need to mix or smudge their liner to realize a smokier look or to create depth. Liquid liners are nice for extra tailor-made seems, like a cat eye.

Waterproof

Based on Michalska, waterproof formulation are positively essentially the most long-lasting, nevertheless, they’ll look tough as soon as they lastly do break down. They is perhaps greatest to make use of in liquid type for those who’re making a cat eye look, as this may dwell on the highest (learn: driest) a part of your lid so the system gained’t break down.

Glide

Whereas pencils that go on tremendous easily may be straightforward to make use of by way of mixing, the truth that they glide on so shortly can truly make them troublesome to make use of for newbies. To see what you consider the pencil’s glide, check it in your hand within the retailer.