The 10 Best Eyeliners of 2023, Tested and Reviewed

[]
The 10 Best Eyeliners of 2023 | Tested by PEOPLE { e.preventDefault(); Mntl.utilities.loadExternalJS( externalJS , () => { Mntl.CMP.onSdkLoaded(() => { OneTrust.ToggleInfoDisplay(); }) }); }, { once: true }); }); Mntl.CMP.init(true, ‘ccpa’, false, 3000); })(); window.Mntl = window.Mntl || {}; Mntl.RTB = Mntl.RTB || {}; Mntl.RTB.setTaxonomyStampValues({“tax1″:”ppl_Shopping”,”tax2″:”ppl_PeopleTested”,”tax0″:”ppl_Homepage”}); Mntl.RTB.setTimeoutLength([750,1250]); Mntl.RTB.Plugins.amazon.amazonConfigs = {“mapTaxValues”:{“tax1″:”ppl_Shopping”,”tax2″:”ppl_PeopleTested”,”si_section”:”ppl_PeopleTested”,”tax0″:”ppl_Homepage”,”tax3″:”null”},”mapFBValues”:{“adunitid”:”mapFBID”},”amazonSlotName”:false,”amazonSection”:”People Tested”}; Mntl.RTB.initVideoBidders([{ type: ‘amazon’, id: ‘3446’ }, { type: ‘prebid’, id: ‘true’ } ]); Mntl.RTB.initDisplayAndOutstreamBidders([{ type: “amazon”, id: ‘3446’},{ type: “msg”, id: ‘true’},{ type: “lotameLightning”, id: ‘true’},{ type: “ixid”, id: ‘true’},{ type: “prebid”, id: ‘true’}]); Mntl.RTB.Plugins.lotameLightning.init({“tax1″:”ppl_Shopping”,”tax2″:”ppl_PeopleTested”,”tax0″:”PEOPLE”,”clientId”:”10692″}); Mntl.RTB.Plugins.prebid.setConfig({“square-fixed/tier1”:[{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446577″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22213″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441990″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_fixed_tier1_300x250″}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060673″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479549″,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboardac/tier3″:[{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier2_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060670″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22210″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479546″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446561″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441988″,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboard-fixed/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446555″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22205″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441982″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_fixed_tier2_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060665″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479541″,”type”:”display”}}],”square-fixed/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446578″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441992″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479550″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060674″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_fixed_tier2_300x250″}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22214″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboardac/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441986″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060667″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446558″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479543″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier1_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22207″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboard-fixed/tier1″:[{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22204″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479540″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_fixed_tier1_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441980″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060664″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446554″,”type”:”display”}}],”square-fixed/tier3″:[{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446579″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441994″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060675″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479551″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22215″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_fixed_tier3_300x250″}}],”leaderboard-fixed/tier3″:[{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441984″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22206″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446556″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060666″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479542″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_fixed_tier3_728x90″}}],”preroll”:[{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”491836″,”type”:”instream”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2442002″,”type”:”instream”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22495″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”instream”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060683″,”type”:”instream”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:578566,”type”:”instream”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479559″,”type”:”instream”}}],”square-fixed/tier4″:[{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441996″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060676″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479552″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_fixed_tier4_300x250″}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446580″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22216″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboardfooter-flex/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22210″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441988″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446561″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479546″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060670″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier2_728x90″}}],”leaderboardfooter-flex/tier1″:[{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441986″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060667″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier1_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22207″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446558″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479543″,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboardfooter-flex/tier4″:[{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22210″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441988″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446561″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479546″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060670″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier2_728x90″}}],”leaderboardfooter-flex/tier3″:[{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441986″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier1_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060667″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22207″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446558″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479543″,”type”:”display”}}],”square-flex/tier1″:[{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446583″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_flex_tier1_300x250″}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060677″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441998″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479553″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22217″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}}],”square-flex/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446549″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2442000″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22220″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060680″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_square_flex_tier2_300x250″}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479556″,”type”:”display”}}],”leaderboard-flex/tier2″:[{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441988″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446561″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479546″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22210″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060670″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier2_728x90″}}],”leaderboard-flex/tier1″:[{“bidder”:”trustx”,”params”:{“uid”:”22207″,”useNewFormat”:true,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”onemobile”,”params”:{“dcn”:”8a9698a4017a7ae782afe89dcbd30047″,”pos”:”peo_leadrbrd_flex_tier1_728x90″}},{“bidder”:”roundel”,”params”:{“siteId”:382319,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”appnexus”,”params”:{“placementId”:”21060667″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”ix”,”params”:{“siteId”:”446558″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”rubicon”,”params”:{“accountId”:”7499″,”siteId”:”426780″,”zoneId”:”2441986″,”type”:”display”}},{“bidder”:”pubmatic”,”params”:{“publisherId”:”158139″,”adSlot”:”3479543″,”type”:”display”}}]}); Mntl.RTB.Plugins.prebid.setPriceGranularity({“buckets”:[{“max”:”20″,”increment”:”0.05″},{“max”:”100″,”increment”:”0.5″}]}); Mntl.RTB.setLatencyBuffer(0); (function(){ const pageTargeting = { customSeries: ” ,tax0: ‘PEOPLE’ ,rid: ‘n3fc5c2deb37e4d88823f2b9ef8d768f123’ ,custom: ” ,sid: ‘n3fc5c2deb37e4d88823f2b9ef8d768f123’ } ; const baseSlotTargeting = { leaid: ‘156569’ ,docId: ‘6746427’ ,viewtype: ” ,type: ‘list’ ,ptax: ‘ppl_PeopleTested’ ,vid: ‘0’ ,tax1: ‘ppl_Shopping’ ,tax2: ‘ppl_PeopleTested’ ,tier: ‘L’ ,leuid: ‘166600909977335’ ,id: ‘6746427’ ,tax3: ” ,tax4: ” ,inf: ‘0’ ,entryType: ‘direct’ ,gtemplate: ‘list’ ,revenueGroup: ‘COMMERCE’ ,chpg: ‘1’ ,t: ‘115’ ,au: ‘156569’ ,jny: ‘0’ ,sbj: ” ,aid: ” ,jnyroot: ” } ; pageTargeting.w = Mntl.utilities.getW(); const initialSlots = []; initialSlots.push({ config: { id: ‘oop’, sizes: [[1, 1]], type: ‘outofpage’, rtb: false, timedRefresh: 0, waitForThirdParty: true }, targeting: Mntl.fnUtilities.deepExtend({}, { pos: ‘atf’, priority: 0 ,floor_id: ‘ed60923b72e14ba9a111a6d06fc03eba’ ,floor: ‘5’ }) }); initialSlots.push({ config: { id: ‘leaderboard-flex-1’, sizes: [[728, 90], [970,90], [970, 250]], type: ‘leaderboard’, rtb: true, timedRefresh: 0, waitForThirdParty: false }, targeting: Mntl.fnUtilities.deepExtend({}, { pos: ‘atf’, priority: 1 ,floor_id: ‘b6bc6b0891744c2daeb1e5104c59a3db’ ,floor: ’25’ }) }); initialSlots.push({ config: { id: ‘square-flex-1’, sizes: [[300, 250],[299, 251],[300, 600],[300, 1050],[160, 600]], type: ‘billboard’, rtb: true, timedRefresh: 0, waitForThirdParty: false }, targeting: Mntl.fnUtilities.deepExtend({}, { pos: ‘atf’, priority: 2 ,floor_id: ‘6383cdc41bb442e583e94b1c44543554′ ,floor: ’30’ }) }); const testIds = Mntl.GPT.getTestIds(); pageTargeting.ab = testIds; pageTargeting.bts = testIds; Mntl.utilities.onLoad(function() { Mntl.utilities.loadExternalJS({ src: ‘//securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js’, async: false }); }); const options = { domain: ‘people.com’, templateName: ‘listsc’, isMobile: false, dfpId: ‘3865’, publisherProvidedId: ‘85121ad7-d2a9-4a25-bd1c-05dd3e199a6f’, singleRequest: false, useLmdFormat: true, useOxygen: true, useInfiniteRightRail: true, bundlePrebid: false, lmdSiteCode: ‘hlt’, pageTargeting, baseSlotTargeting, geo: { isInEurope: false, isInUsa: true }, initialSlots, utils: { generateSlotId: People.GPT.generateSlotId }, displayOnScroll: false, displayOnConsent: true }; if (Mntl.AdMetrics) { Mntl.AdMetrics.init(“6746427”, “n3fc5c2deb37e4d88823f2b9ef8d768f123″, initialSlots.map(slot => slot.config.id), Date.now()); } else { Mntl.AdMetrics = { pushMetrics: () => {} }; } Mntl.GPT.init(options); }());// moved from gtm.ftl so we can initialize GTM only onLoad. From https://support.google.com/tagmanager/answer/6103696?hl=en Mntl.utilities.onLoad(function() { (function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({‘gtm.start’:new Date().getTime(),event:’gtm.js’});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!=’dataLayer’?’&l=’+l:”;j.async=true;defer=true;j.src=’//www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=’+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f);})(window,document,’script’,’dataLayer’,’GTM-P3X3VT7′); }); var dataLayer = dataLayer || []; dataLayer.push({ event: ‘ab-proctor’, ‘abTests-proctor’: { “99-0” : “includeIAS | includeIAS | Include IAS script | 1” , “99-1” : “useOxygen | useOxygen | use the Oxygenated ad unit format and slot names | 1” , “99-2” : “mapFBValues | hasFBMap | Using the FB map values | 1” , “99-3” : “pageLoadDesktopT4 | control | Control (lazy-load) | 0” , “99-4” : “rtbBiddingLatencyBuffer | control | control | 0” , “72” : “adInsertionTimingLazyloadOffset | test1 | adInsertionTimingLazyloadOffset use the recommended combination of placement, timeout and lazyload offset values. | 1” , “99-6” : “hotjarScript | active | active test, has Hotjar | 1” , “63” : “useInfiniteRightRail | active | useInfiniteRightRail (load & destroy) active | 1” , “99-8” : “prebid | ixId | Active with index identity adapter | 2” , “99-9” : “cssJsInjection | control | Control (No Change) | 0” , “99-10” : “rtbTimeout | test2 | test2 | 2” , “99-11” : “rtbTracking | control | | 0” , “99-12” : “commerceButtonOptimization_text | control | control | 0” , “99-13” : “cssJsInjection_tmobiletest | control | control | 0” , “54” : “journeysNextUp | control | Control (no next up recirc) | 0” , “78” : “featuredLinkExternal | buttonNew | Button new style | 2” , “53” : “rightRailOffset | active | active – Move right-rail__offset to content well | 1” , “99-17” : “broadVideo | active | broad video enabled | 1” , “99-18” : “useRTBforVideoAds | active | | 1” } }); dataLayer.push({ envData: { environment: { environment: “k8s-prod”, application: “people”, dataCenter: “us-west-2” }, server: { version: “1.38.0”, title: “people-server” }, client : { browserUA: navigator.userAgent, serverUA: “Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/60.0.3112.113 Safari/537.36”, deviceType: “pc”, usStateCode: “MI” }, mantle: “3.13.711”, commerce: “” } }); (function(win, fnUtils, CMP) { var pageViewDataAsJSON = {“country”:”US”,”description”:”The best eyeliners are easy to apply, provide vibrant color, and stay put all day until it’s time to take your makeup off. We tested dozens of eyeliners and narrowed down the best of the best.”,”contentGroup”:”Other”,”muid”:”85121ad7-d2a9-4a25-bd1c-05dd3e199a6f”,”templateName”:”LISTSC”,”documentId”:6746427,”lastEditingAuthorId”:”156569″,”lastEditingUserId”:”166600909977335″,”templateId”:”115″,”title”:”The 10 Best Eyeliners of 2023 | Tested by PEOPLE ” || document.title || ”,”viewType”:””,”euTrafficFlag”:false,”isGoogleBot”:false,”mantleVersion”:”3.13.711″,”commerceVersion”:””,”primaryTaxonomyIds”:”5324742|5669742|5668751″,”primaryTaxonomyNames”:”People.com|Shopping|People Tested”,”authorId”:”156569″,”revenueGroup”:”COMMERCE”,”fullUrl”:”https://people.com/best-eyeliners-2022-6746427″ + location.hash,”experienceType”:”single page”,”entryType”:”direct”,”excludeFromComscore”:false,”internalSessionId”:”n3fc5c2deb37e4d88823f2b9ef8d768f123″,”internalRequestId”:”n3fc5c2deb37e4d88823f2b9ef8d768f123″,”hid”:””,”experienceTypeName”:””,”recircDocIdsFooter”:”S-6830483|S-6827303|S-6835833|S-5674092|S-6836118|S-6826536|S-6753055|S-6826951″}; var deferLoadTime = 5000; var readyForThirdPartyTrackingEvent = new CustomEvent(‘readyForThirdPartyTracking’, { bubbles: true }); var readyForThirdPartyTracking = fnUtils.once(function() { dataLayer.push({event: ‘readyForThirdPartyTracking’}); window.dispatchEvent(readyForThirdPartyTrackingEvent); }); var readyForDeferredScriptsEvent = new CustomEvent(‘readyForDeferredScripts’, { bubbles: true }); var readyForDeferredScripts = fnUtils.once(function() { dataLayer.push({event: ‘readyForDeferredScripts’}); window.dispatchEvent(readyForDeferredScriptsEvent); }); var hasTargetingConsentHandler = function() { const hasConsent = CMP.hasTargetingConsent(); if (hasConsent) { readyForThirdPartyTracking(); } // if there is consent or the user has closed the banner(AlertBox) in EU then trigger readyForDeferredScripts if (hasConsent || CMP.isAlertBoxClosed()) { readyForDeferredScripts(); } return hasConsent; }; var onRequiredDomEvent = fnUtils.once(function() { if (!CMP) { readyForThirdPartyTracking(); readyForDeferredScripts(); return; } if (!CMP.isLoading()) { hasTargetingConsentHandler(); } CMP.onConsentChange(hasTargetingConsentHandler); }); [ [‘adRendered’, onRequiredDomEvent], [‘beforeunload’, onRequiredDomEvent], [‘load’, function() { setTimeout(onRequiredDomEvent, deferLoadTime); }] ].forEach(function(event) { win.addEventListener(event[0], event[1], { once: true }); }); pageViewDataAsJSON.breakpointName = People.utilities.getW(); pageViewDataAsJSON.bounceExchangeId = ‘2548’; Mntl.utilities.onLoad(function() { Mntl.PageView.init(pageViewDataAsJSON); }); })(window || {}, Mntl.fnUtilities || {}, Mntl.CMP);]]>